Godsforsaken

Chapter 42: A Hole Meant For Pleasure

“Are you ready to have your last virginity taken as well?” I asked the goddess spreading herself open in front of me.

“I am,” Athena whimpered. “Please fuck me. I need to come.”

I was about to reach for the bottle of slime essence but then saw that Alisha already had it. She let a generous dollop run into her palm and then began slathering it onto my cock, getting things nice and slick for me. She knew exactly how to spread the thick slime around without getting me too riled up in the process.

When my cock was coated in a thick layer of the stuff I placed my hands on Athena's thighs and pressed down, canting her hips upward to give me easier access to her ass. Once I was bent over her, Alisha guided my cock to Athena's twitching little rosebud, placing the tip against it.

I applied the tiniest bit of pressure, enough to just nestle my very tip into her wrinkled flesh, and then watched her expression like a hawk, watching for the faintest trace of pain.

There was none but I was nonetheless tempted to wait in this position, to make her beg for it some more. But I had teased her enough already. The way her pussy juices were gushing down, coating both her ass and my cock with yet more lubrication, was proof enough. And so I cut her some slack and eased myself into her awaiting hole, invading her in the one place I hadn't yet claimed for myself.

She was tight enough to strangle my cock inside her but beyond that her insides her silky smooth and hot as a furnace.

“You're... you're in my ass...” Athena whimpered, equal parts ecstasy, fascination and shock in her voice.

“Barely,” I ground out. “You've got another couple inches left to take.”

Her jaw dropped open, a strange combination of eagerness and worry on her face.

“Do it,” Alisha said, sounding more eager even than Athena did.

And so I did. Slowly, achingly slowly, I pressed myself further inside her, spreading her insides open and letting her tight ring of muscle squeeze every inch of my cock. Only when I was all the way inside her, her hole constricting around the base of my cock, did I let up.

“How does it feel, Athena?” I asked. “Do you like having a cock in your ass?”

“Uh-huh,” Athena whimpered, in absolute awe at the way I had filled her up. It was the wrong hole, the one not meant for breeding, and yet I had fit my entire cock in there and she clearly loved the sensation.

“Do you want me to fuck that ass properly?”

“Please,” she whimpered and I complied. I dragged my entire length out of her before pushing back inside, going agonizingly slow so that we could both feel every inch. Well, that and...

“Goddess...” Alisha whined. “It looks amazing...”

“It does,” I agreed, then asked Athena: “Does it feel amazing?”

“Yessss...” Athena hissed. “I... I feel so full...”

“Do you?” Alisha asked, her voice teasing. She slid off from behind me and sat down next to us. She reached out and slipped two fingers inside Athena's neglected pussy. “How about now?”

Athena's eyes flew wide. “Oh stars above...”

Alisha's smile turned into a feral grin as she added another finger. “What about now?”

Athena looked like she was about to lose her mind. She clearly wasn't opposed to this but at the same time she was clearly feeling overwhelmed. And while I would have loved to see her go completely crazy with Alisha's entire hand inside her pussy, the whole point of the exercise was to make her come her brains out from fucking her ass. And so I intervened.

“How about you use those fingers for something a little more useful?” I asked Alisha.

“Did you have something in mind?” she asked.

“Yes,” I said, slowly dragging my cock out of Athena's ass once again. “Grab that slime essence and get your ass ready. You're getting it as soon as I'm done with Athena.”

She bit her lip at that and all but yanked her fingers out of Athena's pussy. The goddess whimpered at the loss and so I shoved my cock back inside her so she wouldn't feel too empty.

“Don't worry, I haven't forgotten about you,” I said as I began laying into Athena, speeding up from the agonizingly slow pace I'd set before.

“You better not,” she whined and it sounded so cute I just had to lean down and kiss her.

I invaded her mouth with my tongue the same way I invaded her ass with my cock, filling her up as much as I could and making her moan. Out of the corner of my eye I saw Alisha bent over, watching us as she reached back to work two fingers into her tight little ass. Oh how I wanted to be inside her, to make her produce those little squeaks and squeals I loved to hear so much.

But that was a joy for later. Right then I was buried inside Athena. She was nearly folded over, my weight pressing down on her, as I sawed in and out of her ass, scraping her sensitive knot of muscle on every pass, making her body shiver and spasm more and more as I kept it up. She was loving it, clearly, but the question still remained whether she could come from it.

“Faster,” she gasped as we broke the kiss for air. “Harder!”

I was only too happy to oblige. Her little hole had gotten used to my size, her insides used to the invasion, and it allowed me to give it to her harder and deeper and faster without fear of hurting her. I had no issue with making her hurt a little bit but there was a world of difference between the pain of a slap or spank and the ache of taking it up the ass harder than one could handle.

Speaking of... “Do you like it up the ass?” I asked.

“Yesss...” she hissed.

“You're my dirty little butt slut tonight, aren't you?”

“Yesss...”

“Say it,” I growled.

“I'm...” She hesitated. It was exactly the reaction I'd wanted.

I slapped her. The impact of flesh on flesh rang out and pink spread across her cheek. “Say it.”

“I'm...”

SMACK.

“I'm... your...”

SMACK.

She scrunched up her face and I was about to slap her again when she yelled: “I'm your filthy little butt slut!”

“Good girl,” I said. “Now open up.”

She opened her mouth on sheer instinct and I spat down into it. I only half hit it, the other half splattering onto her upper lip, and her tongue darted out to lick it up, then looked as though she'd just tasted ambrosia.

“Fucking pervert,” I told her and she grinned as if it was a compliment. Well, if she enjoyed being a pervert...

I dragged my cock all the way out of her and she whimpered at the loss.

“Flip over,” I told her. “On all fours. Time I really worked that ass.”

She didn't hesitate for a moment, turning around and presenting her ass for me. I would have loved to shove her face down into the mattress but I had other plans for her. When she was in position I shoved my cock back inside her ass, burying myself all the way inside her.

“Stars above, it's so deep...” she whined.

“Yeah,” I growled. “I'm going to fill you up as deep as it'll go.”

“Yes please...”

The first time we'd had sex I had choked her while I'd fucked her and while the idea of wringing her throat as her ass strangled my cock did hold appeal I had a different idea this time. And so instead of reaching for her slender throat I curled my fingers into her hair and yanked back, forcing her head backwards, forcing her to look up at me despite me fucking her from behind. And she loved it.

Whatever Athena saw in my gaze, the moment our eyes met her ass clamped down around me as if she was trying to pinch my cock off inside her. It didn't stop me from fucking her but the friction it created was exquisite, like fucking in and out of a clenched fist.

“Cum inside me,” she whined. “Please. Please. Please...”

“You want my cum that bad?”

“Yes! I want your cum in my ass!”

“You're getting it once you come for me,” I told her. “Go wild for me and I'll fill you up so good. Can you do that?”

She got a nasty glint in her eyes at that. “I might if you start fucking me properly.”

I was already giving it to her plenty rough, slamming my cock all the way inside her on every savage thrust, but if that's how she wanted to play it, then that's what I would give her.

I let go of her hair and grabbed hold of her hips. Goddamn but for a formerly virgin goddess of wisdom she had some real breeding hips. Once I had a good grip on her I started driving my cock into her like a battering ram, fucking her as hard as I could, giving her my entire length in brutal thrust after brutal thrust, and using my grip on her hips to pull her onto my cock. The sounds of flesh slapping flesh filled the room and Alisha was staring at us enraptured, fucking three fingers in and out of her ass as she watched Athena taking my cock.

With every thrust the goddess came undone a little bit more, her squeals becoming higher and higher pitched, her breaths growing more and more ragged, and finally she came. Her body seized, then started trembling as a guttural groan tore out of her throat.

It was exactly what I'd been waiting for. I had been on the edge for a while but when I felt her come I stopped holding back, blasting load after load of cum into her ass as her little hole clamped down on me, wringing the seed out of me.

When I had nothing left to give I sat back down on my knees and let go of Athena. Bonelessly she fell forward, her gaping, cream-filled hole sliding off my cock as she dropped onto her belly and lay there breathing like a bellows.

Alisha smirked at me and I gave her a little nod, then circled around the goddess, grabbed her by the hair and pulled her face towards my cock.

“See? This was just in your ass.”

Athena's eyes were glazed over and only came back into focus slowly. When they did she damn near went cross-eyed staring at my cock. “The whole thing?” she asked in awe.

“The whole thing,” I agreed. “Who knew the goddess of wisdom was such a greedy little butt slut?”

Her cheeks grew pink and I thought it kind of amazing that she could still blush after what we'd just done.

“So how about you thank me properly for making you come?”

“What do you expect me to do?” she asked dubiously.

“I think you know,” I said, then gave her a nudge: “Open up.”

She swallowed, clearly thinking about what to do. The way Athena's mind worked I could all but see the thoughts running through her head. She knew intellectually that it was clean, that the powdered unicorn horn had made sure there was no filth on it, but at the same time it had just been in her ass. Even if it was clean the act was still filthy and degenerate. It was unbefitting of a goddess. And that's precisely why she obediently opened her mouth and began lapping at my cock.

As she did Alisha got into place behind her, spread the goddess' cheeks and then buried her face in between them.

Athena's eyes went wide and she sucked in a sharp breath but all the same she never stopped sucking my cock, swirling her tongue around it, worshiping it. And as she did I saw something click into place inside her. She had been jealous of the eager way Alisha had sucked my cock before, had clearly wanted to enjoy it the same way Alisha had, and now she was. Somehow, this far more degrading kind of blowjob was exactly what Athena needed to enjoy it properly.

She buffed me clean, coating my cock in a thick layer of saliva while Alisha worked her tongue deep into her asshole, fishing out as much of my seed as she could and swallowing it down. Athena kept going and going, giving my cock no chance to soften even if I'd cum inside her just minutes ago, and soon it went from half-mast all the way back to a full erection.

Once I was sure I could go again I pulled away from Athena and saw Alisha getting up. I grabbed the little elf and kissed her ravenously, not minding the flavor of my cum on her lips.

“How do you want me?” I asked, my voice like sandpaper.

In response she wrapped her arms around my neck and threw herself onto her back. Of course Alisha wouldn't have been able to pull me over like that but I obliged her, following her down until she was on her back and I loomed over her.

“Make love to me,” she moaned and pulled her legs in close, giving me access to her ass.

Never breaking eye contact I slid on top of her and lined my cock up with her ass. Gods but she had fingered herself good. Her little hole was gaping open, wide enough to accept my tip without having to exert any force at all. It felt as though she were sucking me in, dragging my cock inside her.

I let her. Slowly I pushed myself inside her, aided by the coating of saliva Athena had left on my cock and the generous slime filling Alisha had prepared herself with, producing filthy squelching sounds as I bottomed out inside her.

I kissed her, long and hard and deep, cradling her head as I began to pump into her. This wasn't the savage fucking I had given Athena. Alisha liked it rough most of the time, yes, but when she asked to 'make love', this was what she meant, a slow and gentle pace, forcing her holes to yield to me without hammering into them.

As we kissed I glanced at Athena only to find her staring at us, her palm tracing lazy circles over her pussy. She was clearly loving the view and just as clearly she was wondering what this kind of sex would feel like.

Athena clearly wanted it rough, rougher even than Alisha, but I was getting the feeling that this was merely her desire to make up for lost time, to squeeze as much fucking as possible into each session. But this kind of intimate love-making clearly fascinated her, especially with the way it got to Alisha.

The little elf was moaning and writhing underneath me, going crazy despite the gentle pace. On the one hand this was because her desire for rough sex meant that this slow and gentle approach drove her out of her mind with need but on the other hand it was simply a function of me knowing all her sweet spots. I knew how to work her holes just so, how much of my weight to rest on her, how to hold her and how to kiss her, to get her riled up as much as possible.

And Athena was clearly desperate to know what that felt like. Perhaps she didn't know just how many months I'd spent finding out all of the little elf's likes and dislikes or perhaps she did know and wanted to reach the same level of intimacy with me, wanted me to learn the rhythm of her body the same way I had learned Alisha's. It would require us to spend far, far more time with each other and clearly that was what she wanted. Clearly what she wanted out of this was far more than just to spend some time scratching the itch I'd awakened inside her.

And it was a testament to just how easy she was to read that I could get all of this out of her staring at us with a hand between her thighs.

But right now I wasn't doing it with Athena. I was making love to Alisha, the contrast between the gentle kisses and slow pace and the fact that I was balls-deep inside her ass enough to drive me wild. And it was not just driving me wild. I knew enough about Alisha's reactions that I could tell she was coming again and again on my cock. They weren't the huge, spectacular orgasms I knew the little elf was capable of but she was still going wild on my cock again and again, each orgasm making her ass clamp down on me and making it harder and harder for me to hold on.

And so, when I could no longer hold back, when she had managed to drive me to the absolute brink, I let go. I didn't baste her ass full force the way I had Athena. This hadn't been that kind of sex. Instead I felt myself filling Alisha up, pumping more and more inside her in long, drawn-out spurts that left her slack-jawed and panting.

“I love you,” I whispered quietly once I had nothing more to give her.

“I love you, too,” she whimpered.

And then I chanced a look over to Athena. She instantly averted her gaze but not before I saw the faintest look of jealousy on her face.